That absolutely makes sense, yes. I can see her running up to him if he ever returned and smacking him before holding him as tight as she could!

Agreed about her not ever being able to really let go - elves are like that in general, of course, with the whole 'only one love ever' thing (unless your name is Finwe), so it makes perfect sense that she wouldn't be able to, even if his personality hadn't been quite so magnetic and overwhelming in life.